The Trial RecordIndependent publication · John Hajicek

Kansas City, Missouri

Adam L. Caine

Who makes the trial record?

Independent commentary by Mormonism.com

Missouri’s official manual identifies three distinct jobs in Adam L. Caine’s path to the bench. He clerked for Judge J. Dale Youngs, led a trial team in the Jackson County prosecutor’s office, and served as an assistant United States attorney in the Western District of Missouri. Governor Michael Parson appointed him to the circuit court in April 2020. Missouri voters retained him in 2022.

An exhibit has to reach the record

Division 11 publishes witness and exhibit lists, a standing order on deposition behavior and a set of trial policies. Those are particularly revealing documents for a reader tracing a case from preparation to the courtroom. A witness, a lawyer asking a question and a judge ruling on an objection perform different acts. A newspaper account that assigns them all to the court makes the public record harder to understand.

What the transcript can conceal

Consider two pieces of paper a citizen can read without attending a trial. Division 11’s deposition order describes a practice that a transcript may record as an innocent interruption. A question is pending. Counsel confers privately with the witness. The order draws the line at a conference intended to influence the answer. It also addresses an objection framed so that the witness hears the answer counsel wants before giving testimony. The speaking order on the page matters as much as the words themselves.

The division’s exhibit sheet asks about a different sequence. There is room to record an offer, an objection and the receipt of an exhibit. A document described on the list may have been the very item the judge refused to receive. When I read an account which says that a document proved a claim at trial, I want the exhibit number, the ruling and the testimony that identified it. Those three references let another reader test the claim.

John Hajicek, editor

As a historian who has also been a litigant, I care which words a witness actually supplied and which came from the lawyer. The distinction also matters when a prosecutor seeks public office. I want readers to have the documents from which to judge a lawyer’s work. Division 11’s public rules offer a place to begin.

On the record

Official Manual of the State of Missouri · judicial branch, p. 253Division 11 · standing orders and exhibitsDivision 11 · deposition conduct, one-page orderDivision 11 · blank exhibit sheet